Some links on our site may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Updated September 2026: rebuilt after CPSC recall 25-393 — the recalled Intex Ultra XTR Frame (18′ x 52″) and Summer Waves Elite (16′ x 48″) are no longer recommended here. Picks re-verified against currently sold pools that sit below the recall’s 48-inch line.
Prices are approximate, current as of publication, and change frequently — confirm the latest price with the retailer before buying.
Verdict up front: a federal recall took two of this page’s three original picks off the table. CPSC recall 25-393 covers roughly five million Bestway, Intex and Polygroup (Summer Waves) above-ground pools 48 inches and taller, after nine child drownings. We don’t recommend products under an open recall. Full stop. Below the 48-inch line, two pools are still easy to actually buy: the Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ at about $399.99 direct from Intex, and the Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ at about $419.99 at Walmart. The Intex is the one we’d pay for. The numbers are below.
What Did Recall 25-393 Take Off the Table?
On July 21, 2025, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission announced recall 25-393: about five million above-ground pools sold in the U.S. since 2002 (plus roughly 266,000 in Canada), all of them 48 inches or taller, all with a compression strap that runs around the outside of the pool over the vertical support legs. Per the CPSC, that strap “may create a foothold” — a child can step on it, climb in unattended, and drown. Nine children, ages 22 months to 3 years, drowned this way between 2007 and 2022.
The recalled lines, per the CPSC notice: Bestway’s Power Steel and Steel Pro and Coleman Power Steel pools (2008–2024); Intex’s Metal Frame and Ultra Frame (2002–2012) and Prism Frame and Ultra XTR Frame (2024–2025); and Polygroup’s Summer Waves (2015–2025), Summer Escapes, Funsicle, Sand n Sun and Blue Wave pools. That includes both the Intex Ultra XTR Frame 18′ x 52″ and the Summer Waves Elite 16′ x 48″ this comparison originally recommended. They’re out. We don’t promote items under an open recall, whatever their warranty math looked like.
Already own one? Walk around your pool. If the wall is 48 inches or taller and a strap wraps horizontally around the outside, over the legs, check your brand and model number — the CPSC says they’re printed on the outside of the pool liner — against the recall notice. The remedy is a free repair kit from the manufacturer: a rope that attaches to each vertical support pole at ground level and wraps around the pool, after which you cut off and remove the original compression strap. Contact your pool’s maker for the kit before the pool is used again. Don’t rely on the strap check alone; use the model list in the notice.
One more thing worth saying plainly: as of early September 2026, Intex’s own Prism Frame product pages still list 48-inch-and-taller pools for sale with no mention of the recall or of a redesigned strap. We can’t verify that current 48-inch-plus stock from any of these three brands is built differently than the recalled units. Until a maker’s own page verifiably says so, no 48-inch-or-taller pool from Bestway, Intex or Polygroup gets a recommendation here.
What Can You Still Buy Under 48 Inches?
The recall’s floor is 48 inches. A 42-inch pool from these same brands sits below it — no compression-strap recall, per the CPSC notice’s own scope. Under that line, two pools are in stock at mainstream prices right now: the Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ (model 26719EH, about $399.99 direct at intexcorp.com) and the Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ (model 56687E, about $419.99 at Walmart). Both capacities below are the makers’ published figures at 90% fill, so the per-gallon math compares like with like.
| Pool | Price (approx.) | Capacity (90% fill) | Price per 1,000 gal | Wall height |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ (26719EH) | $399.99 (intexcorp.com) | 3,357 gal | $119.15 | 42″ — below recall line |
| Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ (56687E) | $419.99 (Walmart) | 3,955 gal | $106.19 | 42″ — below recall line |
The arithmetic, since sticker prices on different-sized pools mislead: $419.99 ÷ 3.955 thousand gallons = $106.19 per 1,000 gallons for the Bestway; $399.99 ÷ 3.357 = $119.15 for the Intex. The Bestway’s extra foot of diameter buys you about 600 more gallons for $20 more. On water-per-dollar alone, Bestway wins. That is the last category it wins.
And Summer Waves? Effectively off the table. Polygroup’s Summer Waves pools from 2015–2025 in the 48-inch-plus heights are in the recall, and the one sub-48-inch Elite we could find in stock anywhere — a 14′ x 42″ at Quad City Pools, a regional dealer — was listed at $1,150 and marked low stock. That’s nearly triple what Intex charges for the same 14-foot footprint. No Summer Waves pick this year. Skip the brand until it has a strap-free pool in stock at a sane price.
Whose Warranty Outlasts the First Season?
This page’s original finding still holds in miniature: pool warranties run on calendar days, not swim seasons, and most expire before a second summer. Here’s the claims check — what each maker says, against what its own paperwork supports.
| The claim | The sourced reality | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Bestway’s Walmart listing calls the Steel Pro MAX “corrosion & puncture resistant” | Bestway USA’s own product-warranties page backs frame pools — and its filter pumps — for 180 days from purchase or delivery | Durability talk with a six-month receipt |
| Intex’s product page for the 26719EH states a “1-year limited warranty” | Stated in writing on the maker’s own listing; twice Bestway’s coverage, and the longest we found under 48 inches | Holds — but it’s the ceiling of this market, not the floor |
| Intex’s cartridge guidance, quoted on Walmart’s Type A listing: replace “every 2 weeks” | Following that cadence costs about $5.00 per swap on the Intex and $19.99 per swap on the Bestway (math below) | The same advice is cheap on one pool and expensive on the other |
Neither warranty reaches a second summer intact. Buy the Intex in June and a pump that quits the following July is your bill. But 365 days versus 180 is not nothing: the Intex is covered through the fall teardown, winter storage, and next spring’s setup — the stretch where owners discover the leaks. The Bestway’s coverage is done by Thanksgiving.
What Will Cartridges Cost You Every Season?
Both sets run 1,000 GPH-class cartridge pumps, and this is where the two pools quietly diverge. Intex’s Type A cartridge — the size Intex lists for its 1,000 GPH pumps — runs $19.99 for a 4-pack at Walmart, or $5.00 each ($19.99 ÷ 4). Bestway’s Type III — the cartridge Bestway lists for its 530–1,500 GPH pumps, the range this set’s pump sits in — runs $19.99 for a single cartridge at Home Depot. Same twenty dollars. One buys four filters, the other buys one.
What that does to a season depends on how often you swap. Intex’s own guidance, quoted on Walmart’s cartridge listing, is every two weeks; plenty of owners stretch to monthly. Call the swim season 12 weeks — Memorial Day to late August — and here’s both cadences, so you can see the span isn’t doing the arguing:
| Pool | Cost per swap | Every 2 weeks (6 swaps/season) | Monthly (3 swaps/season) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ | $5.00 (Walmart 4-pack) | $30.00 | $15.00 |
| Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ | $19.99 (Home Depot) | $119.94 | $59.97 |
At the maker-recommended cadence, the Bestway costs roughly $90 more per season to filter than the Intex — nearly a quarter of its purchase price, every year, forever. At the lax cadence it’s still $45 more. The $20 the Bestway saves per 1,000 gallons at checkout is gone by August.
The Ledger: Which Pool Wins on the Numbers That Repeat?
Four axes, weighted. Warranty gets triple weight because pump failure is the most commonly reported problem in owner reviews across both brands, and the warranty decides who pays for it. Cartridge cost gets double weight because it recurs every season while the sticker price stings once. Price per 1,000 gallons gets double weight as the honest, size-adjusted sticker. Raw sticker price gets single weight — it’s the number you feel once. Winner of an axis takes 2 points, loser takes 1, times the weight.
| Axis (weight) | Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ | Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warranty length (×3) | 1 year — 6 pts | 180 days — 3 pts | intexcorp.com product page; bestwayusa.com product-warranties page |
| Cartridge cost per swap (×2) | $5.00 — 4 pts | $19.99 — 2 pts | Walmart (Intex Type A 4-pack); Home Depot (Bestway Type III) |
| Price per 1,000 gallons (×2) | $119.15 — 2 pts | $106.19 — 4 pts | intexcorp.com and Walmart prices ÷ makers’ 90%-fill capacities |
| Sticker price (×1) | $399.99 — 2 pts | $419.99 — 1 pt | intexcorp.com; Walmart |
| Tally | 14 | 10 | — |
On what owners report: across both brands, the pattern in reviews and pool-forum threads is the same two failure points — pump motors wearing out first under all-summer run time, and liners failing early when the ground underneath wasn’t leveled and covered. We haven’t found evidence either brand is meaningfully more failure-prone than the other at equal setup quality, and we did not physically test these pools ourselves. Which is exactly why the warranty axis carries the weight: when the common failure arrives, coverage is the difference between a claim and a second purchase.
Which One Gets Nate’s Money?
Tie-breaker: the Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″. It’s $20 cheaper at checkout, carries twice the warranty, and costs a quarter as much per cartridge swap. The Bestway’s only win is more water per dollar, and its cartridge bill hands that advantage back within one season at the recommended swap cadence. If I’m writing the check, it’s the Intex, direct from intexcorp.com at $399.99.
Skip the Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ if maximum swim area per dollar is genuinely your only axis — the Bestway’s 15-foot ring delivers about 600 more gallons at $106.19 per 1,000 versus $119.15.
Skip the Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ if you’ll run the pump all season — $19.99 per Type III cartridge at the recommended cadence is about $120 a summer — or if you want any coverage still standing 181 days after delivery.
Skip anything 48 inches or taller from Bestway, Intex or Summer Waves until the maker’s own page verifiably states the compression strap is gone from current production. As of this update, we found no such statement anywhere.
Already own the pool and want to keep it clean without daily netting? Our comparison of robotic pool cleaners covers automated options built for exactly this kind of frame pool. If the kids in your house aren’t ready for 42 inches of water yet, we’ve also compared water tables, splash pads, and sprinklers for smaller-scale water play. And once the pool’s up, round out the yard with our backyard games comparison for what to do while it fills. For more seasonal picks, browse our Beach & Backyard buying guides.
What Else Do Pool Owners Want to Know Right Now?
Is my above-ground pool included in the 2025 CPSC recall?
CPSC recall 25-393 covers Bestway, Intex and Polygroup (Summer Waves and related brands) above-ground pools 48 inches and taller that use a compression strap running around the outside of the pool over the vertical support legs — about five million pools sold since 2002. The brand and model number are printed on the outside of the pool liner; check them against the model list in the CPSC notice.
What should I do if I own a recalled pool?
Contact the manufacturer for the free repair kit. Per the CPSC, the kit is a rope that attaches to each vertical support pole at ground level and wraps around the pool; once it’s installed, you cut off and remove the original compression strap. Until the repair is made, the CPSC’s guidance is to ensure children cannot access the pool unattended, or to drain it.
Can I still buy an Intex or Bestway pool that isn’t recalled?
Yes — below the recall’s 48-inch line. The Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ (about $399.99 at intexcorp.com) and the Bestway Steel Pro MAX 15′ x 42″ (about $419.99 at Walmart) are both 42-inch pools, outside the recall’s scope. We found no 48-inch-or-taller pool from these brands whose maker verifiably states current stock is redesigned, so we recommend none of them.
Which non-recalled pool has the longer warranty?
The Intex Prism Frame 14′ x 42″ carries a 1-year limited warranty, stated on Intex’s own product page. Bestway’s product-warranties page backs its frame pools and filter pumps for 180 days. Neither reaches a second summer, but the Intex covers teardown, storage, and next spring’s setup; the Bestway’s coverage ends about six months after delivery.
What does a season of filter cartridges actually cost?
At the two-week replacement cadence Intex recommends, a 12-week season is six swaps: about $30 on the Intex (Type A cartridges, $19.99 per 4-pack at Walmart, $5.00 each) versus about $120 on the Bestway (Type III, $19.99 per cartridge at Home Depot). At a monthly cadence it’s roughly $15 versus $60.
