Some links on our site may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Shopping for the best rowing machine means comparing two different products wearing the same shape: exercise hardware and a content subscription bolted to it. Over five years, a $990 Concept2 RowErg stays a $990 purchase, while a $1,995 Hydrow Wave quietly becomes a $4,600 one once its membership is counted. That single table — further down — decides this comparison more than any spec sheet, so we lead with the numbers and let the machines argue afterward.
The verdict table first
| Machine | Price | Resistance | Subscription | Weight capacity | Our call |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Concept2 RowErg | $990 | Air + magnetic flywheel | None — PM5 monitor is standalone | 500 lb | Best overall |
| Sunny Health & Fitness SF-RW5801 | $249.99 | Magnetic | None | 285 lb | Best budget |
| Aviron Strong Go | $1,599 | Air + magnetic | Optional, $19.95/mo (games library); bring your own tablet | 507 lb | Best for the workout-averse |
| Hydrow Wave | $1,995 | Computer-controlled magnetic | $44/mo for classes; limited Just Row mode without | 375 lb | Best studio experience |
| Ergatta Luxe | $2,499 | Water | $29/mo for the game platform | 500 lb | Best-looking machine in the room |
Prices and specs above are as published in Garage Gym Reviews’ 2026 rower testing and Rowing Related’s model reviews; membership rates are the current figures from those outlets and StartRowing’s Hydrow membership review. All of it moves with promotions, so treat the relationships, not the digits, as the durable fact.
What does a rowing machine really cost over five years?
This is the original math this page exists for. Assume you keep the machine five years and pay each brand’s standard membership the whole time — the usage pattern these companies’ content libraries are built around. At three workouts a week, that is roughly 780 sessions:
| Machine | Hardware | 5 years of membership | 5-year total | Cost per workout |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sunny SF-RW5801 | $249.99 | $0 | $250 | $0.32 |
| Concept2 RowErg | $990 | $0 (optional apps exist) | $990 | $1.27 |
| Aviron Strong Go | $1,599 | $1,197 ($19.95 × 60) | $2,796 | $3.58 |
| Ergatta Luxe | $2,499 | $1,740 ($29 × 60) | $4,239 | $5.43 |
| Hydrow Wave | $1,995 | $2,640 ($44 × 60) | $4,635 | $5.94 |
Read that last column carefully. The Hydrow Wave costs less than the Ergatta Luxe on day one and more by year three, because its membership is half again as expensive. And the Concept2’s five-year total is less than a quarter of either — the gap pays for a very nice vacation, or for the treadmill in our small-space cardio comparison. The honest counterargument: if a $44 membership is the difference between rowing and not rowing, it is the cheapest line in the table. Know which buyer you are before you defend either answer.
Concept2 RowErg: the default for a reason
The RowErg is the machine competitive rowers train on, and its spec sheet explains the loyalty: a 500 lb capacity, a PM5 monitor that tracks splits, watts, and stroke rate on two D-cell batteries with no account required, and — per Rowing Related’s review — a 2-year limited warranty with parts availability stretching past fifteen years. It separates into two pieces for storage and resells so well that used prices barely dip.
Its weaknesses are the flip side of its virtues. There is no screen, no classes, and no gamification unless you bolt on a third-party app, and the air flywheel is the loudest resistance type here. It is gym equipment, not furniture. Buy it if you want the machine your grandkids could still row; skip it if you know a blank monitor means you will stop showing up.
Hydrow Wave: the class act
The Wave is the compact version of Hydrow’s studio concept: a bright touchscreen, instructors filming on real water, and computer-controlled magnetic resistance that keeps the machine quiet enough for an apartment. Per StartRowing’s membership review, the $44-per-month All-Access plan is where the product actually lives — without it you are left with a limited Just Row mode, which is a lot to leave dark on a $1,995 machine. Its 375 lb capacity is also the lowest of the smart rowers here.
Buy it if live-style coached classes are what get you on the seat, and budget the subscription as part of the price. Skip it if you resent recurring fees — this is the most expensive five-year total in the comparison.
Ergatta Luxe: rowing as a video game, in furniture clothing
Ergatta takes the opposite bet from Hydrow: no instructors, just races, targets, and games rendered on a screen above a water tank in a handsome wooden frame. The water resistance is the most rowing-like feel you can get at home and the whoosh is genuinely pleasant. At $2,499 it is the priciest hardware here, and its $29 monthly platform fee lands its five-year total north of $4,200.
Buy it if competition motivates you more than coaching and the machine will live somewhere guests can see it. Skip it if you want flat-water quiet — a water tank has opinions — or if the total-cost table above already made your eye twitch.
Aviron Strong Go and Sunny SF-RW5801: the two smart compromises
The Aviron Strong Go is the value play among the entertainment rowers. You supply the tablet, and Aviron’s arcade-style games — the membership is $19.95 a month per Garage Gym Reviews, and optional — do for rowing what a podcast does for a commute. With dual air-magnetic resistance and a 507 lb capacity, the hardware is more serious than the price suggests. Its drawback is exactly its pitch: no built-in screen, and games rather than coaching.
The Sunny SF-RW5801 is the honest bottom rung: $249.99, magnetic, quiet, foldable, no subscription anywhere in sight. Its 285 lb capacity and lighter build mean serious rowers will outgrow its resistance ceiling, but as a way to find out whether you are a rowing person at all, it is one-quarter the price of finding out on a RowErg.
How we compared
We compared current 2026 models on published price, resistance type, capacity, subscription structure, and warranty, drawing specs from Garage Gym Reviews’ hands-on rower testing, Rowing Related’s model reviews, and StartRowing’s membership analysis, weighed against the consistent themes in long-term owner feedback — monitor reliability, noise, and whether the content keeps people rowing past month three. The five-year cost model is our own arithmetic on those published rates. We claim no hands-on testing of our own, and our full process is documented in our editorial standards. More home training comparisons live in our Health & Fitness section.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to pay a subscription to use a smart rower?
Usually you keep basic functionality without one. Hydrow’s Just Row mode, Aviron’s free metric tracking, and Ergatta’s basic modes all work unsubscribed, but each machine’s defining experience — classes, games, races — sits behind the monthly fee. The Concept2 and Sunny are the two here designed to be complete with no subscription at all.
Is rowing enough exercise on its own?
Rowing works most major muscle groups and is a legitimate full-body cardio base, which is why it anchors our rower vs elliptical vs bike comparison. Most training plans still pair it with some resistance work for bone and muscle strength, and anyone with back concerns should get form guidance early — poor rowing form is a lower-back tax.
Which rowing machine is quietest for an apartment?
Magnetic resistance is the quiet option, which favors the Hydrow Wave and the Sunny. Water rowers produce a rhythmic swish most neighbors tolerate, while air flywheels like the Concept2’s are the loudest of the three types — fine in a garage, noticeable through an apartment floor at 6 a.m.
How much space does a rowing machine need?
Plan on a footprint around 8 feet by 2 feet in use — the Concept2 measures 96″ long — plus elbow room. Storage is where they differ: the Concept2 splits in two, the Sunny folds, and the Hydrow Wave stands vertically with an accessory kit. Measure the ceiling before planning to store anything upright.
Bottom line
The Concept2 RowErg is the best rowing machine for most people because it is the only premium option whose price is the whole price. Pay Hydrow’s toll if coached classes are what move you, Ergatta’s if competition is, Aviron’s if you need rowing disguised as a game, and Sunny’s $250 if you are still dating the sport rather than marrying it. Whichever you pick, recovery matters as much as the meters — our massage gun face-off covers the day after.
