Some links on our site may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Published July 23, 2026. Prices and specs checked September 2, 2026.
Five rowing machines, two different products wearing one shape. Two of these are exercise hardware, full stop. Three are hardware with a content subscription bolted on, and that subscription is the whole decision. A $990 Concept2 RowErg stays a $990 purchase for as long as you own it. A $1,995 Hydrow Wave becomes a $4,995 one over five years once its membership is counted in. That gap is bigger than it was the last time we ran this math. Hydrow, Ergatta, and Aviron have all raised their subscription prices since. Numbers first, arguments after.
I have rowed on air and water machines over the years, and what I remember after the first month is the flywheel noise and the monthly fee. The machine you keep using is the one that is cheap to keep using.
Rowing Machine Five-Year Cost: Hardware Plus Membership
Assume you keep the machine five years and pay each brand’s standard month-to-month membership the whole time. There is no annual prepay and no promo rate, just what a new subscriber is quoted today. At three workouts a week, that’s roughly 780 sessions. Here’s what five years actually costs, hardware plus subscription, verified against each company’s current pricing page:
| Machine | Hardware | Membership (60 mo., standard rate) | 5-year total | Cost per workout |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sunny SF-RW5801 | $199.99 | $0 — none exists | $200 | $0.26 |
| Concept2 RowErg | $990 | $0 — PM5 monitor is standalone | $990 | $1.27 |
| Aviron Strong Go | $1,599 | $2,040 ($34/mo × 60) | $3,639 | $4.67 |
| Ergatta Luxe | $2,199 | $2,340 ($39/mo × 60) | $4,539 | $5.82 |
| Hydrow Wave | $1,995 | $3,000 ($50/mo × 60) | $4,995 | $6.40 |
Hardware prices are current retail as listed on each maker’s own site (Concept2.com, Hydrow.com, Ergatta.com, avironactive.com). Sunny’s Walmart listing was checked this month. Membership rates are each company’s own standard month-to-month price. They were pulled directly from company sites, not from a promotional annual-plan rate. All three subscription machines let you pay less by committing for a year or more up front. We used the plain monthly number because that’s the price a new buyer sees at checkout. Locking into a multi-year contract is its own decision. Read the last column carefully. Concept2’s five-year total is roughly a fifth of Hydrow’s. The gap only exists because of a recurring fee that has nothing to do with how well either machine rows.
Which Rowing Machine Claims Hold Up Today?
Prices aren’t the only thing that moved. Checking each company’s own current pages against what buyers commonly assume turned up three things. One is a capacity disagreement. Another is an ownership change nobody announced loudly. The last is a retailer price spread wide enough to matter.
| Machine | What’s commonly assumed | What the maker’s own page says now | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Concept2 RowErg | 500 lb weight capacity, full stop | Concept2’s own site rates it 500 lb under US testing — and 300 lb under the European standard, a separate figure on the same page | True, with an asterisk most buyers never see |
| Concept2 RowErg | A simple “2-year warranty” | Concept2’s warranty page splits coverage: 2 years on moving parts and the monitor, 5 years on frame parts | Better than advertised, not worse |
| Hydrow Wave | $44-a-month membership | Hydrow’s own pricing page and blog both now list All-Access at $50 a month | Price increase, confirmed on two of Hydrow’s own pages |
| Ergatta Luxe | An independent company | Interactive Strength Inc. (Nasdaq: TRNR) completed its acquisition of Ergatta on March 11, 2026, per the company’s own closing announcement | Ownership changed; the founders still run day-to-day operations per TRNR’s release |
| Sunny SF-RW5801 | A fixed budget price | Walmart currently lists it at $199.99; Staples lists the identical model at $285.19 | Same rower, an $85 retailer spread — shop around |
Is the Concept2 RowErg the Best Rowing Machine?
The RowErg is the machine competitive rowers train on. The spec sheet explains the loyalty. It has a 500 lb US-rated capacity. Its PM5 monitor tracks splits, watts, and stroke rate on two D-cell batteries with no account required. The two-tier warranty runs longer than most owners expect on the parts that matter most. It separates into two pieces for storage and holds resale value well. A five-year-old unit still sells for most of what it cost new.
Its weaknesses are the flip side of its virtues. There’s no screen, no classes, no gamification unless you bolt on a third-party app. The air flywheel is the loudest resistance type in this comparison. It’s gym equipment, not furniture. Skip this if a blank monitor means you stop showing up — the RowErg doesn’t do any of the convincing for you.
Is the Hydrow Wave Worth the Monthly Fee?
The Wave is still the compact version of Hydrow’s studio concept. It has a bright touchscreen, instructors filming on real water, and computer-controlled magnetic resistance quiet enough for an apartment. What’s different is the toll. All-Access membership now runs $50 a month, up from the $44 this page quoted before. That is confirmed on both Hydrow’s product page and its own membership blog post. Without it, you’re left with a limited Just Row mode on a machine that costs up to $1,995 to buy. Its 375 lb capacity also remains the lowest of the three smart rowers here.
Buy it if coached, studio-style classes are what actually gets you rowing three times a week. Budget the subscription as part of the sticker price rather than an afterthought. Skip this if you resent recurring fees — the Wave now carries the highest five-year total of anything in this comparison.
Ergatta Luxe: New Owner and a Higher Membership Price
Ergatta takes the opposite bet from Hydrow. It has no instructors, just races, targets, and games rendered above a water tank inside a handsome wooden frame. The water resistance is the closest thing to outdoor rowing you’ll get indoors. At $2,199 it remains the priciest hardware in this lineup. Two things changed since we last checked. First, the membership. Ergatta’s own pricing page lists $39 a month standard, not the $29 this page quoted before. That lower number is real, but it only applies if you prepay three years ($1,044) up front. Second, the company itself. Interactive Strength Inc., a publicly traded fitness holding company, closed its acquisition of Ergatta on March 11, 2026. Ergatta’s founders are staying on to run the business day to day, per the deal’s own announcement. But “who backs this if something goes wrong” is now a different answer than it was.
Buy it if competition motivates you more than coaching and the machine will live somewhere guests can see it. Skip this if you want the lowest possible five-year cost among the subscription rowers. At $4,539, Ergatta runs second to Hydrow’s $4,995 rather than clearly cheaper.
Aviron Strong Go: What the Membership Costs Now
The Aviron Strong Go is still the value play among the entertainment rowers. It has dual air-magnetic resistance and a 507 lb capacity. Its arcade-style games do for rowing what a podcast does for a commute. You supply the tablet. What’s changed is the toll. Aviron’s own membership FAQ and shop page both now list the standard monthly plan at $34, not the $19.95 this page cited previously. You can still get to $29 a month, but only by committing to a full year upfront ($348) rather than paying as you go.
Buy it if you want serious hardware at entertainment-tier engagement and you’re comfortable committing annually to hit the lower rate. Skip this if month-to-month flexibility matters more than the $5 a month it costs you. The games-over-coaching pitch is the same either way, and there’s still no built-in screen.
Sunny SF-RW5801: Same Rower, Two Retail Prices
The Sunny SF-RW5801 is the honest bottom rung: magnetic, quiet, foldable, no subscription anywhere in sight. Its 285 lb capacity and lighter build mean serious rowers will outgrow its resistance ceiling. But it exists to answer one question cheaply: are you actually a rowing person? It costs a fraction of what it takes to find out on anything else here. The catch is that the exact same model lists for $199.99 at Walmart and $285.19 at Staples right now. Nothing about the hardware differs between those two prices. Check more than one retailer before you buy.
Buy it if you want the cheapest possible way to test whether rowing sticks. Skip this if you already know you’ll want coaching or gamification — the SF-RW5801 offers neither, by design.
Prices are approximate, current as of publication, and change frequently — confirm the latest price with the retailer before buying.
Which Rowing Machine Should You Buy?
The Concept2 RowErg is still the best rowing machine for most people. The case got stronger, not weaker, since every subscription competitor raised its price. Pay Hydrow’s $50 monthly toll if coached classes are what move you. Ergatta’s $39 makes sense if competition is, understanding a public company now owns the platform. Aviron’s $34 suits you if you need rowing disguised as a game. Or spend Sunny’s $199.99 — shop around, it’s also sold for $285 — if you’re still dating the sport rather than marrying it. Recovery matters as much as the meters. Our mid-range massage gun comparison covers the day after. If noise is the real constraint, our apartment cardio noise comparison and our rower-vs-elliptical-vs-bike breakdown cover what else fits a shared floor.
