Some links on our site may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
Updated August 2026: We reorganized this guide around real buying scenarios instead of a brand-by-brand rundown, and added verified August 2026 dimensions, weights, and prices for all three grills so you can check trunk space and storage before you buy.
Picture the back of your car packed for a weekend — cooler, chairs, a tent if you’re camping — and now a portable grill has to fit in whatever space is left. Or picture a balcony where every square foot of storage is already spoken for. The right portable grill isn’t the one with the best reviews in the abstract; it’s the one whose actual footprint, packed size, and weight fit the space and situation you’re grilling in.
The short answer: For most buyers, the Weber Q1200 is the best all-around pick — it’s the lightest true stand-up grill of the three at 31 pounds and folds down to a 15.5-inch-tall package. If your cooking style is big-batch flat-top food rather than classic grill marks, the Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle with Hood packs 267 square inches of cooking surface into the smallest footprint here. And if you’re feeding a crowd and don’t mind rolling instead of lifting, the Coleman RoadTrip 285 has the largest cooking area of the three at 285 square inches.
Our verdict at a glance
- Best overall: Weber Q1200 — lightest true stand-up grill here, with even cast-iron grate heat in a genuinely portable package.
- Best for tight storage: Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle with Hood — the smallest footprint of the three, at $159 the least expensive.
- Best for feeding a crowd: Coleman RoadTrip 285 — largest cooking area (285 sq. in.) and a wheeled cart that does the carrying for you.
For feeding a crowd off one cooking surface
The Coleman RoadTrip 285 is the pick here: at 285 square inches, it has the largest cooking area of the three grills compared in this guide, and its stand-up, wheeled cart design means you roll it to the tailgate or campsite rather than lifting it. Set up, it measures 32.1" L x 18.5" W x 15.45" H and folds down to roughly 31 inches tall for transport, per Coleman’s own product listing. At 47.8 pounds it’s the heaviest grill here by a wide margin, but because it travels on wheels, that weight matters far less than it would on a grill you have to carry.
Who should buy it: tailgaters and campers who need to feed a group and can roll the grill from car to site rather than carry it. Who should skip it: anyone tight on trunk space, since at 32.1" long set up it’s also the longest grill compared here.
For a balcony or patio where every inch of storage matters
The Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle with Hood is built for exactly this. Because it’s a tabletop unit with no legs or cart, its assembled footprint is just 18.75" L x 22.25" W x 12.25" H and it weighs 35.2 pounds, smaller and lighter than either grill-style option here, per an independent CleverHiker review that measured the unit directly. It still delivers 267 square inches of flat cooking surface — nearly as much as the largest grill on this list — in a fraction of the storage space, and it opens up smash burgers, breakfast spreads, and stir-fry that a grate simply can’t cook.
Who should buy it: balcony and patio cooks who need the smallest footprint, and anyone who wants griddle-style cooking (smash burgers, breakfast, stir-fry). Who should skip it: anyone who wants true grill marks and fat that drips away, since a flat top can’t replicate that. Bringing drinks along too? Our insulated bottle comparison pairs well with a cookout.
For camping trips where you’re lifting the grill in and out of a trunk
When you’re the one carrying the grill — not rolling it — weight is the deciding factor, and the Weber Q1200 wins it: at 31 pounds it’s the lightest of the three grills here, according to Weber’s own published specifications. Its folding legs and side tables collapse it to 40.9" W x 16.5" D x 15.5" H for transport, and its 189-square-inch cast-iron grate heats evenly enough for consistent sears and char.
Who should buy it: car campers and cabin-trip cooks who lift the grill in and out of a trunk repeatedly and want classic grill marks. Who should skip it: anyone who wants the biggest possible cooking area or true griddle versatility.
Size, fit, and space matrix
| Attribute | Weber Q1200 | Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle w/ Hood | Coleman RoadTrip 285 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cooking area | 189 sq. in. | 267 sq. in. | 285 sq. in. |
| Set-up footprint (W x D x H) | 40.9" x 20.5" x 24.6" | 22.25" x 18.75" x 12.25" | 18.5" x 32.1" x 15.45" |
| Packed / folded size | 40.9" x 16.5" x 15.5" | Same footprint; griddle and hood detach from base to reduce transport height | Folds to roughly 31" tall on wheels |
| Weight | 31 lbs | 35.2 lbs | 47.8 lbs |
| Price (verified Aug. 2026) | $279.00 | $159.00 | $389.99 |
Dimensions and weights above are drawn from each manufacturer’s own product listing, except the Blackstone unit’s assembled dimensions and weight, which come from an independent CleverHiker review since Blackstone’s own listing doesn’t publish them. Prices were checked directly against Weber.com, Blackstone’s retail listings, and Coleman.com in August 2026.
How we compared
We looked for the patterns that recur across large numbers of owner reports gathered over many cookouts and seasons, because a grill shows its true character after dozens of uses, not on the first burger. We compared across heat evenness and searing, verified real-world dimensions and weight, versatility of the cooking surface, ease of cleaning and maintenance, and outdoor durability. Because these three represent different cooking formats, we focused on matching the tool to the scenario rather than crowning one universal winner. Our full research and sourcing approach is documented on our editorial standards page.
Prices are approximate, current as of publication, and change frequently — confirm the latest price with the retailer before buying.
Frequently asked questions
Which portable grill has the largest cooking surface?
The Coleman RoadTrip 285 has the largest cooking area of these three at 285 square inches, followed by the Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle at 267 square inches and the Weber Q1200 at 189 square inches.
Which one takes up the least storage space?
The Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle with Hood has the smallest assembled footprint of the three at 18.75" L x 22.25" W x 12.25" H, since it’s a tabletop unit with no legs or wheeled cart to store.
Which grill is easiest to carry, not roll?
The Weber Q1200 is the lightest of the three at 31 pounds, compared to 35.2 pounds for the Blackstone griddle and 47.8 pounds for the Coleman RoadTrip 285, making it the best choice when you’re lifting the grill rather than rolling it.
Do I need a grill grate, a griddle, or both?
A grate like the Weber’s gives you grill marks, char, and fat that drips away, ideal for steaks, burgers, and vegetables. A griddle like the Blackstone excels at smash burgers, breakfast, and anything that would fall through grates. Many enthusiasts eventually want both.
Does the Coleman RoadTrip 285’s weight matter if it has wheels?
Less than it would otherwise. At 47.8 pounds it’s the heaviest grill compared here, but its stand-up cart design and wheels mean you roll it rather than lift it, which matters most if you’ll need to carry it up stairs or over uneven ground where wheels don’t help.
Bottom line
Because these three are genuinely different formats, the right pick depends on where you’ll store it and how you’ll get it there, not just how it cooks. If you’re carrying the grill yourself, the Weber Q1200’s 31-pound, 15.5-inch-tall folded package is hard to beat. If storage space is the real constraint, the Blackstone 17" Tabletop Griddle’s compact footprint delivers 267 square inches without needing legs or a cart. And if you’re feeding a crowd and can roll instead of lift, the Coleman RoadTrip 285’s 285-square-inch surface is the largest here. For more outdoor gear, browse our Outdoors & Travel guides.
