Some links on our site may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more.
This article is general information, not veterinary advice. Diet is a medical decision for your dog — consult your veterinarian before choosing or changing food, especially for a dog with any health condition.
Published July 12, 2026. Updated October 10, 2026.
Between 2018 and 2022, the FDA ran the most-watched inquiry in pet food. It investigated reports of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM), a serious heart condition, in dogs eating certain diets, most of them labeled grain-free. The agency logged 1,382 canine DCM reports from January 2014 through November 2022. It never established that any diet causes the disease. In December 2022 it announced it would stop issuing routine updates unless meaningful new scientific information emerged. That unresolved ending, real signal with no proven cause, is the honest starting point for the grain free dog food decision in 2026.
Quick answer: For most healthy dogs, a well-formulated grain-inclusive food from a maker with real veterinary-nutrition expertise remains the sensible, evidence-backed default. Grain-free earns its place mainly when a veterinarian identifies a specific need. Per current research from Tufts, the sharper question may not be grains at all. It may be how heavily a formula leans on pulses like peas and lentils, in either category. Decide with your vet, not the front of the bag.
I have bought a lot of pet food over the years, mostly for cats, and the lesson carries over to dogs. The front of the bag is marketing. The ingredient panel and the nutritional adequacy statement on the back are where the real information sits. A bag that shouts about what it leaves out tells you little about what it puts in.
Grain-free vs grain-inclusive dog food: how do they compare?
| Attribute | Grain-free | Grain-inclusive |
|---|---|---|
| Main carbohydrate source | Peas, potatoes, legumes | Rice, corn, oats, barley |
| Best for | Veterinarian-identified needs, such as a confirmed grain allergy | Most healthy dogs |
| Evidence base | Still developing; central to the FDA’s DCM inquiry | Long track record of formulation and feeding trials |
| Typical price tier | Mid to premium | Budget to mid |
| Pulse content (per Tufts guidance, check either label) | Often high in peas and lentils | Can also be pulse-heavy |
| Vet consult advised | Strongly | Recommended |
What did the FDA conclude about grain-free dog food?
It reached no conclusion that grain-free food causes DCM, and it says so in its own words. The FDA opened the investigation in July 2018 after reports of DCM in dogs without the usual breed predisposition. Per the agency’s investigation page, more than 90 percent of products named in reports through April 2019 were grain-free. Ninety-three percent contained peas and/or lentils.
By the final tally reported with its December 23, 2022 statement, covered by the AVMA, the agency had received 1,382 canine DCM reports from January 1, 2014 through November 1, 2022. The majority were filed between 2018 and 2020. Only 255 arrived from August 2020 through November 2022. The FDA’s own caveat is explicit: adverse event numbers, by themselves, “do not supply sufficient data to establish a causal relationship with reported product(s).” It called the matter a complex scientific issue that may involve multiple factors. It said it would provide further updates only if meaningful new scientific information emerges. As of August 2026, its investigation page shows no update since December 2022.
Are grain allergies common in dogs?
No, and the best-known data points at proteins, not grains. A 2016 review of adverse food reactions in BMC Veterinary Research by Mueller and colleagues covered 297 dogs with diagnosed food reactions. It found beef implicated in 34 percent of cases, dairy in 17 percent, and chicken in 15 percent, with wheat at 13 percent. Food allergy of any kind is itself uncommon relative to how often it is suspected. It also cannot be reliably self-diagnosed. Persistent itching or digestive upset has many possible causes. A veterinarian-guided elimination diet is the standard way to identify a true trigger before switching foods.
Do dogs need grains in their diet?
No, but grains are not filler either. Whole grains like rice, oats, and barley contribute digestible energy, fiber, and micronutrients. Most dogs digest cooked grains well. Grain-free formulas do not remove carbohydrate. They replace cereal grains with other starches, typically peas, lentils, chickpeas, and potatoes. So neither label tells you whether a food is well made. The formula and the maker separate good food from bad far more than the presence or absence of grain does. Look for companies that employ qualified veterinary nutritionists and run feeding trials.
What does the newest DCM research show in 2026?
The cause is still unidentified, but the picture has sharpened away from grains as such. In a June 2026 update from Tufts University’s Petfoodology program, veterinary nutritionist Dr. Lisa Freeman notes that more than 30 scientific studies have now been published on diet-associated DCM. She says the disease “does not appear to be caused by a lack of grains or a deficiency of taurine or other nutrients.” It is associated with diets high in pulses, meaning peas, lentils, chickpeas, and beans. That includes both grain-free and grain-inclusive formulas.
Her team also reports a urine biomarker finding in affected dogs. It suggests phospholipidosis, an abnormal fat metabolism, as a lead on the mechanism. The update notes that diet-associated DCM can slowly improve when the diet is changed, especially if caught early. That is a finding to act on only under veterinary care.
Do grain-free dog food claims hold up against the record?
| The marketing claim | What the evidence and the FDA record support |
|---|---|
| “Grain allergies are common, so grain-free helps most dogs” | Not supported. In the Mueller 2016 BMC Veterinary Research review of 297 food-allergic dogs, wheat accounted for 13 percent of implicated allergens, behind beef (34%), dairy (17%), and chicken (15%). Food allergy itself is uncommon. |
| “Grain-free is more natural and lower in carbs” | Not supported on carbs. Grain-free formulas swap grains for other starches. Per the FDA’s report data, 93 percent of named products contained peas and/or lentils, and 42 percent contained potatoes or sweet potatoes. |
| “Grain-free prevents health problems” | No demonstrated preventive benefit. The FDA record instead associates the reported DCM cases predominantly with grain-free, pulse-rich diets. That is an association, not established causation, per the agency’s own December 2022 language. |
| “Grains are just filler” | Not supported. Whole grains supply digestible energy, fiber, and micronutrients. Per the June 2026 Tufts update, lack of grains is not what the DCM evidence points to. Pulse-heavy formulation is the live question. |
How should you choose grain-free or grain-inclusive dog food?
Choose with your veterinarian, using your dog’s specifics rather than the category label. For most healthy dogs, a grain-inclusive formula from an established maker with veterinary-nutrition staffing and feeding trials is the default that carries the fewest open questions. It typically costs less at comparable quality. Grain-free belongs in the plan when a vet identifies a reason, such as a confirmed allergy to a specific grain found through an elimination diet.
Whichever direction you go, current Tufts guidance makes the ingredient panel worth a look. Watch for heavy reliance on peas, lentils, chickpeas, and beans, since pulse-rich recipes exist on both sides of the grain divide. Transition any food change gradually over several days to a week. Involve your vet if anything seems off.
How were these two diets compared?
This guide is built from primary and expert sources named where they appear. They are the FDA’s own investigation page and its December 2022 statement as reported by the AVMA, the June 2026 Tufts Petfoodology research update, and the Mueller 2016 allergen review in BMC Veterinary Research. All were re-verified in August 2026, in line with our editorial standards. The DCM question remains scientifically unsettled, so the record is reported precisely: association documented, causation not established. Every individual-dog decision routes to a veterinarian. Diet interacts with age, breed, activity, and existing conditions. Treat this as the framework for that conversation, not a prescription. More pet guides are available in our Pets section.
Grain-free dog food questions, answered
Did the FDA recall any grain-free dog food over DCM?
No. The FDA’s DCM inquiry was an investigation, not an enforcement action. It issued public updates naming report counts and diet characteristics. No DCM-related recall or finding of violation resulted. The agency explicitly stated that the reports alone could not establish a causal relationship.
Can dogs with diet-associated DCM get better?
Sometimes, per the researchers studying it. The June 2026 Tufts Petfoodology update notes that diet-associated DCM can slowly improve if the diet is changed, especially if caught early. Diagnosis and any diet change for a cardiac condition belong entirely with your veterinarian and, where indicated, a veterinary cardiologist.
Does choosing grain-inclusive food avoid the DCM concern entirely?
No. Per the June 2026 Tufts update, the association is with diets high in pulses such as peas, lentils, chickpeas, and beans. Both grain-free and grain-inclusive foods can be formulated that way. The grain label alone is not the screen. The ingredient list and your vet’s read on it are.
Is grain-free dog food lower in carbohydrates?
No, not inherently. Grain-free kibble replaces cereal grains with other starch sources. In the FDA’s report data, 93 percent of named products contained peas and/or lentils and 42 percent contained potatoes or sweet potatoes. A dog needing a genuinely different macronutrient profile needs a veterinarian-selected diet, not a label swap.
Is grain-free dog food worth it after the FDA inquiry?
The FDA’s inquiry ended without a proven cause but with a documented association that responsible owners should not wave away. The reported cases clustered in pulse-rich, mostly grain-free diets. For most healthy dogs, well-made grain-inclusive food remains the default with the longest track record and the fewest open questions. Grain-free remains a legitimate tool when a veterinarian identifies the need. Read the ingredient panel for heavy pulses either way, and make the final call in the exam room, not the pet-food aisle. For more pet care comparisons, visit our Pets section.
